The following West Chester University student-athletes have earned CoSIDA Academic All-America as one of the top student-athletes in the country for that specific sport. In order to be eligible for voting, a student-athlete must maintain above a 3.30 cumulative grade-point average, be at least a sophomore in athletic eligibility and have been selected to the CoSIDA Academic All-District squad that same season. Since 1983, a total of 47 WCU student-athletes have been selected Academic All-America. In 2005-06, West Chester University women's swimmer, Tammy Leane, was selected All-America of the Year in the Women's At-Large category.
 

CATEGORY	NAME	POSITION / SPORT	TEAM
1983 (1)
Football	Eric Wentling	PK
1986 (1)
Football	Gerald Desmond	KS	1st team
2000 (1)
Women's At-Large	Kim Rochon	Women's Lacrosse	2nd team
2001 (2)
Women's At-Large	Kim Rochon	Women's Lacrosse	1st team
Men's At-Large	Grant Clark	Men's Swimming	2nd team
2002 (2)
Women's At-Large	Megan Straehle	Women's Swimming	2nd team
Men's At-Large	Ryan Weathers	Men's Swimming	3rd team
2003 (2)
Women's At-Large	Megan Straehle	Women's Swimming	3rd team
Men's At-Large	Ryan Weathers	Men's Swimming	2nd team
2005 (1)
Women's Soccer	Julie Karcher	F	2nd team
2006 (2)
Women's At-Large	Tammy Leane	Women's Swimming	1st team
Women's Soccer	Julie Karcher	F	1st team
2009 (1)
Women's Soccer	Jessica Bennett	D	1st team
2010 (2)
Women's At-Large	Kristen Montello	Women's Swimming	1st team
Women's Soccer	Jessica Bennett	D	1st team
2012 (2)
Women's At-Large	Allie Aquila	Women's Gymnastics	2nd team
Baseball	Joey Wendle	2B	1st team
2013 (2)
Women's At-Large	Michele Schrift	Field Hockey	2nd team
Women's At-Large	Nancy Stehman	Field Hockey	1st team
2014 (2)
Women's At-Large	Nancy Stehman	Field Hockey	1st team
Men's At-Large	David McCormick	Men's Swimming	2nd team
2017 (3)
Women's At-Large	Tess Hayward	Women's Swimming	2nd team
Softball	Sara Ercolani	INF	3rd team
Men's Soccer	Givanny Mowrey	F	1st team
2018 (2)
Softball	Sara Ercolani	INF	3rd team
Baseball	Jared Melone	1B	1st team
2019 (4)
Women's At-Large	Kaitlin Hatch	Field Hockey	3rd team
Men's At-Large	Dylan North	Men's Swimming	3rd team
Softball	Emily Maseth	DP	1st team
Baseball	Jared Melone	3B	1st team
2020 (2)
Softball	Emily Maseth	DP	1st team
Softball	Bri Garber	INF	1st team
2021 (1)
Softball	Bri Garber	INF	1st team
2022 (4)
Football	Michael Gobora	Defensive Line	2nd team
Women's At-Large	Jessica Meakim	Women's Gymnastics	1st team
Women's At-Large	Ann Carozza	Women's Swimming & Diving	2nd team
Women's Track and Field	Madison James	Multi's	1st team
2023 (7)
Women's Soccer	Kiley Kergides	Defense	3rd team
Women's Basketball	Leah Johnson	Guard	3rd team
Women's Swimming	Ann Carozza	Fly/Sprint/Free	2nd team
Men's Swimming	Logan Brockway	IM/Fly/Backstroke	3rd team
Men's Swimming	Dalton Fink	Fly/Backstroke	3rd team
Women's At-Large	Hannah Stanislawczyk	Women's Lacrosse	2nd team
Women's At-Large	Jessica Gorr	Women's Lacrosse	3rd team
2024 (1)
Men's Soccer	Daniel Good	GK	2nd team
2025 (2)
Men's Swimming	Kolos Nagy	Freestyle/Backstroke/IM	3rd team
Women's At-Large	Keri Barnett	Women's Lacrosse	2nd team