Magill played basketball at Lower Merion High School. While still in high school, Magill started personal basketball training and assisted his father's program Irv Magill's Courtsense Basketball.

Magill helped coach West Chester's Special Olympic basketball team as a sophomore and was the assistant high school men's varsity basketball coach at the Jack. M. Barrack Hebrew Academy, taking them to the league championship.

Currently, Magill is a junior at West Chester University studying Health and Physical education.